By Edie Eckman
Edie Eckman instructing a virtual crochet course.
Many craft industry instructors have switched from in-person teaching to in-studio teaching. Teachers and students alike are learning to navigate this new virtual workshop world on the fly, but some best practices are emerging. Let’s take a look at some things you can do to make sure your next virtual workshop runs smoothly and leaves students eager for more.
Synchronous vs. Asynchronous Instruction
One of the first decisions you need to make is whether your workshop will be synchronous or asynchronous. Synchronous learning simply means that the teacher and students are in the same virtual space at the same time. The interaction takes place in real time as it would in person, in a classroom.
Platforms like Zoom, Skype, Facetime, WebEx and others can be used for real-time, face-to-face instruction for small or large groups.
With asynchronous learning, the instructor presents a video or other materials that the students can access on their own schedule. Back-and-forth communication between instructor and students is more limited. The student can ask questions and make comments, but there may be a lag between the time the question is asked and the instructor responds.
Platforms like Zoom, Skype, Facetime, WebEx and others can be used for real-time, face-to-face instruction for small or large groups.
With asynchronous learning, the instructor presents a video or other materials that the students can access on their own schedule. Back-and-forth communication between instructor and students is more limited. The student can ask questions and make comments, but there may be a lag between the time the question is asked and the instructor responds.
Platforms like YouTube, Craftsy, Creativebug, plus a number of online course platforms and learning management systems provide asynchronous instruction.
A hybrid model that includes both types of learning can also be effective. Think of a Facebook, YouTube or Instagram Live: the instructor teaches and responds to comments from viewers in real time and also perhaps after the livestream is over.
Studio Set-Up
You don’t have to spend a lot of money on your studio set-up, but there are some basics you’ll want to observe.
- A strong internet connection is important. Don’t rely on WiFi if you don’t have to; an ethernet connection is best.
- Two (or more) cameras will allow you to switch back and forth between your face and your hands. Depending on what you are teaching, you may want to have a close-up shot of your hands, as well as a mid-range or wide-range shot of a larger workspace. For starters, you can use the camera on your computer and a smart phone. Use the best cameras you have available, especially for any detail shots. You may want to invest in an additional webcam or document camera. If you do, make sure the refresh rate is sufficient to avoid choppy video.
- Adequate lighting is key. Shine the light on your face; a back-lit head is not your friend. Ensure adequate lighting on your workspace, as well. Ambient lighting will change with the time of day and even the weather. Check your lighting under different conditions and make adjustments as needed.
- If possible, use a wired headset for better audio.
- Backgrounds matter. Clean, uncluttered backgrounds are best for head shots, while well-lit, high contrast backgrounds may be best for hands-on shots. Watch for distracting shadows and annoying ceiling fans. Avoid virtual backgrounds if possible; they are usually more distracting than helpful.
Manage Student Expectations
Many students are new to this virtual learning model and they may not know what to expect or how to behave. It’s up to you to make them comfortable enough to learn effectively.
Communicate supplies and materials needed well before the workshop. Be very specific about supplies, remembering even the smallest items (scissors, needle and thread, specific type of yarn, pencil, paper for taking notes). Allow time for special materials to be ordered or gathered, and for any homework to be completed. If there is a handout, provide it in time for students to print it out. Send out a reminder about how to access the class and about having supplies handy. Refer them to articles to help prepare them for online learning.
Make sure each student knows the basics of how to use the platform. Do they need to be able to unmute themselves? Turn their camera on and off? Share their screen? Do you want students to ask questions as they occur, or do you prefer that they wait until you ask for questions? Do you want them to ask questions in a chat or Q&A space, or do you want them to raise their hands (either physically or virtually)? Do you want them to remain mute until you call on them?
What do you plan to cover, and how? If you need to see student’s work to give feedback, how do you want them to present it? Although it is nice to be able to see each student’s face and their reactions, some students may not be comfortable having their cameras on throughout the class.
Lesson Planning
I’m sorry to have to tell you this, but you really do need to plan your lessons specifically for virtual learning. Even if you’ve taught the same in-person workshop for years, you’ll need to make some changes.
Break down each lesson into smaller, easily digestible chunks. There’s a lot of non-verbal learning that takes place in person, but in a virtual space we don’t get those nonverbal signals. Think about how you would describe the steps to a blind person. Practice using your words.
The number of students you can handle and the length of the lesson may also need to change. Expecting students to pay attention to a screen for several hours at a time may be unreasonable. Consider breaking up a longer class into smaller parts or providing a long break between lessons.
At this point, the jury is still out on best practices for class lengths and class numbers. As more events go virtual, and as teachers and students become accustomed to online workshops, consensus may form around these issues.
Consider incorporating short videos, polls, breakout rooms, slide shows, and other resources to your presentation. However, don’t go overboard with media! Especially in a synchronous class, students are there to hear and see you.
Practice
As with any new knowledge, it takes practice to master virtual instruction. Try out different set-ups with friends to see what camera angles and lighting arrangements work best. Teach a mini-lesson or two to allow you to practice switching cameras or refining your descriptions.
Put yourself in the student’s shoes and take a few online classes. Make notes on what worked and didn’t work from an instructional standpoint. What would you like to emulate and what do you want to avoid?
Steph Newman of Crowned Sparrow Craft Co. suggests checking that your equipment is working about 30 minutes before each class. “It may seem tedious, but it definitely can eliminate panic when it’s not working five minutes before class starts.”
Crowned Sparrow Craft Co. has moved to hosting a virtual “Craft Night In” instead of their in-person workshops. Kits for this embroidery project get mailed to you before and class is held via Zoom.
With time and practice, you’ll adeptly meld technology set-up, lesson planning, and class management into a seamless online experience.
Go in-depth on these topics and more with Edie’s virtual workshop How to Teach Knitting & Crochet Online. It’s for fiber artists of all types, not just yarnies.
Edie Eckman
contributer
Edie Eckman is a knit and crochet author, designer, teacher, blogger and technical editor. Since Covid-19 has kept us home, she has successfully made the transition to online teaching. Find her at edieeckman.com.
I am wanting to teach online using Zoom, but so far I have not discovered how to add a 2nd camera that can be accessed during the class session. I have gone into share screen and then the advanced tab, it shows the options of camera 1 and camera 2 but they are only the front view and the rear view of my tablet’s webcam. someone said to plug my phone (my other camera) directly into my tablet. I have done that but it doesn’t show up. Any answers?
Try logging into the Zoom meeting with another device (your phone, for example) and using that as your second camera.
Ev Roth, you will need to log in on Zoom with two different email accounts – one on your computer/tablet and the other on your phone. You can then ‘spotlight’ your phone when you want to show that camera angle. To me the bigger trouble is not having an echo between the two devices, even with your phone volume turned all the way down.
Would love to know if someone has the work-around on that one!
I’m teaching virtual sewing classes via Zoom and I do sometimes use the double-device set up for handwork classes. My workaround for sound is to simply have my phone (the one on my hands) muted within Zoom, and I have the classes arranged so that I give an intro via my laptop screen, and then when my students need to get stitching and focus on my hands, I ask them to “pin” that screen until I complete that demo and tell them they can “unpin” it. It’s not perfect, but I don’t have any sound issues!
You can also add your phone then once in the zoom meeting disable the sound from the phone using an option under the mute button. You won’t have any sound feedback. Just muting the phone doesn’t always work, disabling works all the time.
I have my own question for the group: I have a ton of natural light in my studio, and throughout the summer, I really relied on that to help light my classes without shadows. My classes are all live, and all in the evening, and now that the seasons are changing, I need to improve my lighting without spending a fortune, and there’s just such a sea of options out there, it’s so hard to tell what’s garbage and what’s worthwhile. Does anyone have any suggestions for specific lighting products that are versatile and reasonably affordable? Thank you!
Hi Julie, I just interviewed Clara Nartey for the podcast (this episode will air soon) and she has been teaching online for several years. She recommends this ring light which has a small tripod and phone mount. I’m not sure if a phone setup is what you were searching for, but I figured I’d pass this recommendation along: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07Q3471S2/?coliid=I1NILRWDQ2FLOT&colid=99YDDUJYP79R&psc=1&ref_=lv_ov_lig_dp_it
That is incredibly helpful, I really appreciate it so much! Thank you, Abby!